theohall wrote: bb2112 wrote: RMC wrote:
theohall wrote:Sadly..... I can trust bb2112.....
no one else yet....
Really? After last game? BB should be the last person to trust. He had half the players believing everything he said...And it was all lies...
Now, now. It was not all lies. I said Remus was a wolf and that I thought RMC and Q human.
I am more interested on how Theo trusts me. Did you use a card to tell I'm a villager? And if so, why is that sad?
It is sad, because I SO want to lynch you.....
Unfortunately, I 'know' this would be wrong.
Yes, I used the Free Scan card on bb2112 and he is a Villager, as am I, or I would have little reason to use the Card. The only reason a Wolf would have to use the card is to find the Light Mage. Now, the Wolves have zero chance of using that card to find the Light Mage.
2 of the 13 in-game are Villagers... bb2112 and myself.
Which should not stop the lynch of Remus West or Chaosraven. IMO, one of the triumvirate (bb2112, Chaosraven, Remus West) will turn up evil. With RW turning up Evil the last two games, knowing bb2112 is a Villager, tbat leaves Chaosraven.
Which is why my vote is where it is and not moving.
This is what any trust in theo would hinge on. At the time, I read the highlighted part found myself reading this an nodding along.
But if you put on the Conspiracy Cap we made from Chaos' hide, you'll see that a Wolf or Villager would do the same thing. A wolf scans bb2112 looking for the Light Mage and comes up blank. What does he do? Why not
announce it? The card is used, you know
the Light Mage, so there is no risk in confirming someone who will come back to haunt you, and on the plus side, you get some cred for point it out. And it's not like you can keep the card more than one day, so you have
to use it that day rather than let the Village get a chance to get it and find you.
So nothing theo did there points to his inherent Villager-ness. Which is the argument I was going to make yesterday in place of the Remus lynch. It made more sense then, though, as with 2 possible wolves, lynching theo as a Villager would "prove" bb2112 to the same level as today whereas getting him as a Wolf would be just as good. Now, though, there is no added benefit.
Hence, my Order of Lynching:
Trig wins the game if he is the wolf.
As does BB2112 as there was only like a 2% chance he got the card he needed and managed to get scanned after playing it. I'll take those odds.