Re: Scoop's Inhumans - Game has begun
Posted: Sun Apr 19, 2015 4:35 pm
That is not dead which can eternal lie, and with strange aeons bring us some web forums whereupon we can gather
http://www.octopusoverlords.com/forum/
+1Lagom Lite wrote:
Sorry, having a bad day. A work friend of over 15 years passed away on Friday and I went to the viewing today. I am very sad. He was a great guy and we had some good times together.stessier wrote:This is going to be a tremendously one sided conversation though as Rev can only quote us. So BB2112 - convince me you're a good guy. No pressure.
LL! Good to see you!Lagom Lite wrote:
I don't think you are doing the bot thing right. You have to pull complete sentences, not parse them. But it doesn't really matter. I'm going to say I'm innocent and not the convert, you are going to say you are innocent and not the convert in your bot fashion. I know the truth that the Revbot is our convert. I figured it out yesterday when I figured it couldn't be Stess or RMC. Either way, Stess has a decision to make. And Scoop a question to answer. I really wanted to say I had the canister today and the fact I dont is bugging me.RevHempus71 wrote:Rev can only quote us. BB2112
Anyway, I was sure I, being the only humanbot I was going to use that as my proof. Or semi proof.
Anyway, I am human, don't have the canister, and am not confused. Revbot is our human.
Rev, I will make this easy for you. I am Revbot and I am not evil convert.
Yeah, how would this prove anything at all? I would assume Rev would have said it at dawn had I given him the words.bb2112 wrote:Anyway, this game has me very confused. I was sure I was going to get the canister today being the only human, but I do not have it. I was going to use that as my proof. Or semi proof because I am sure converted Revbot would also spoof having the canister if he could get the sentence together.
It wouldn't I guess. That is why I backed off my original statement of using it as my proof. But I would still like an answer to my question on why I didn't get the canister when I woke up this morning. Even if you got the steal canister role, I would have had to have the canister for you to steal it. Puffing is the last thing that happens in the night. Unless there was a small window where you puffed, stole the canister, all before dawn, and before I could posess it, but I don't think that works in the rule set. So back to confusion. I guess we will see when Scoop gets back.stessier wrote:Yeah, how would this prove anything at all? I would assume Rev would have said it at dawn had I given him the words.bb2112 wrote:Anyway, this game has me very confused. I was sure I was going to get the canister today being the only human, but I do not have it. I was going to use that as my proof. Or semi proof because I am sure converted Revbot would also spoof having the canister if he could get the sentence together.
bb2112 wrote:No, if you were the UO, you would have ended the game already. I am pretty convinced you are not the UO, otherwise you would be a huge A-hole for dragging this out.stessier wrote:Well, from my perspective anyway. Could be me too.
stessier wrote:Just waiting on Scoop.
I guess this is why everyone rushed to lynch anyone that I spoke about in a cross manner.Scoop20906 wrote: El Guapo - Human Trusted
2 out of 2, you were on a roll... I wouldn't have touched you but I scanned you on the 2nd night and couldn't risk you coming out as the proven one.El Guapo wrote:I guess this is why everyone rushed to lynch anyone that I spoke about in a cross manner.Scoop20906 wrote: El Guapo - Human Trusted
Once it looked like Stess was innocent, I was I was going to go after you.. I tried to make you(well still wasn't sure it was you) think I was going to go after Rev, which I thought would keep me alive.. <sigh> Oh well..bb2112 wrote:Bummer, I wanted to see which way Stess would jump at the end.
It was tough deciding who to kill that last night. I changed my mind between Stess and RMC at least 10 times. It was also too bad the canister went to Stess the second to last day. RMC was ready to go after Stess over the Vorret vote.
And El G, you led us to kill our seer day 1! Our village tendency of outing or killing our seer day 1 is still going strong.
Scoop, I would definitely play again. Creative rule set, although you need to work on the ending. If the canister would have been used up after Stess used it because there were no more nights, that would have kept the game going.
Nope. What finally decided me on killing you is that in every game we play you go after me. It now has become a pattern. I think I might have mentioned you are always wrong at some point in some game or other and that has turned you into a bb hating machine.RMC wrote:Once it looked like Stess was innocent, I was I was going to go after you.. I tried to make you(well still wasn't sure it was you) think I was going to go after Rev, which I thought would keep me alive.. <sigh> Oh well..bb2112 wrote:Bummer, I wanted to see which way Stess would jump at the end.
It was tough deciding who to kill that last night. I changed my mind between Stess and RMC at least 10 times. It was also too bad the canister went to Stess the second to last day. RMC was ready to go after Stess over the Vorret vote.
And El G, you led us to kill our seer day 1! Our village tendency of outing or killing our seer day 1 is still going strong.
Scoop, I would definitely play again. Creative rule set, although you need to work on the ending. If the canister would have been used up after Stess used it because there were no more nights, that would have kept the game going.
hehe.. Hell I am still holding a grudge from the time we played board games in Chicago and you won.bb2112 wrote:Nope. What finally decided me on killing you is that in every game we play you go after me. It now has become a pattern. I think I might have mentioned you are always wrong at some point in some game or other and that has turned you into a bb hating machine.RMC wrote:Once it looked like Stess was innocent, I was I was going to go after you.. I tried to make you(well still wasn't sure it was you) think I was going to go after Rev, which I thought would keep me alive.. <sigh> Oh well..bb2112 wrote:Bummer, I wanted to see which way Stess would jump at the end.
It was tough deciding who to kill that last night. I changed my mind between Stess and RMC at least 10 times. It was also too bad the canister went to Stess the second to last day. RMC was ready to go after Stess over the Vorret vote.
And El G, you led us to kill our seer day 1! Our village tendency of outing or killing our seer day 1 is still going strong.
Scoop, I would definitely play again. Creative rule set, although you need to work on the ending. If the canister would have been used up after Stess used it because there were no more nights, that would have kept the game going.
Was I converted and never told?Scoop20906 wrote:Moliere - Inhuman Seer
You died before you could be converted.Moliere wrote:Was I converted and never told?Scoop20906 wrote:Moliere - Inhuman Seer
At least you didn't have to post everything as a Haiku outside of accusations. Yes, one of the mods did that and I had that role.RevHempus71 wrote:Click click brrrr beep. Revbot here. Fun and frustating role.
Will play again.
Me too!!bb2112 wrote:Bummer, I wanted to see which way Stess would jump at the end.
I'm interested in the fact that you were apparently assuming that the canister holder would spray everyone day 1 (which almost happened). Both thematically and game-wise I feel like it should be set up so that spraying everyone is a desperate last resort (high risk high reward) gamble, not as a no-brainer. If it should be sprayed day 1, why not just dispense with the canister and give everyone powers to begin with? For that matter, why would the UO be looking for it?Scoop20906 wrote:
2. bb2112 had the Terrigen Mist on night one and chose to spray it on everyone. However, the Unspoken One/Vorret had other ideas and killed him. No, he didn't bb2112 had the canister. This through everything off as I thought everyone would have powers.
Carefull not to give too much power to the humans, as a lone wolf you're seriously walking on egg shells all game long, I got lucky once the game almost ended on N3 and I didn't do anything bad at all since it was all pure randomness.El Guapo wrote:I'm interested in the fact that you were apparently assuming that the canister holder would spray everyone day 1 (which almost happened). Both thematically and game-wise I feel like it should be set up so that spraying everyone is a desperate last resort (high risk high reward) gamble, not as a no-brainer. If it should be sprayed day 1, why not just dispense with the canister and give everyone powers to begin with? For that matter, why would the UO be looking for it?Scoop20906 wrote:
2. bb2112 had the Terrigen Mist on night one and chose to spray it on everyone. However, the Unspoken One/Vorret had other ideas and killed him. No, he didn't bb2112 had the canister. This through everything off as I thought everyone would have powers.
It's also kind of odd that the UO is better off having the humans spray everyone than stealing the canister and using it, since the results are identical except that if the humans spray everyone then the UO gets another human death out of it.
One suggestion: remove the part where a human user dies if they spray everyone, and as before the humans can huff the canister individually. Make one of the humans at start be the Scientist (or something). Both the Scientist and the UO are scanning for Unobtanium held by a random human. If either finds it then everyone gets sprayed, but if the Scientist finds it the spray is better for the humans and if the UO finds it the spray is better for the Inhuman side. (either an extra power for someone, or an extra kill or something, whatever makes sense in terms of balancing).
Anyway, fun game - I would play again.
One of the other unseen advantages of not spraying everyone by the human side was the cannister became a way to prove people in the end game. If everyone was sprayed right out of the gate, I beilieve it becomes a 2 miss game. So the advantage is with the UO when everyone is sprayed. The one thing I quite haven't figured out yet is everyone gets sprayed, the next logical step is for the whole village to come out. If anyone is spoofing a role, then it cuts the odds to 50/50 and it gets even better if the seer can be protected/survives for one night. 2 people claim seer, 2 people claim messenger. You know you have 2 wolves out of 4. Real seer already knows other seer is a fake, so scans one of the messengers and figures out which one of them is fake. Then as soon as the village figures out which seer is telling the truth, you can nail 2 baddies right in a row. Not sure who the UO would fake, but whoever it is, the real one would know.El Guapo wrote:I'm interested in the fact that you were apparently assuming that the canister holder would spray everyone day 1 (which almost happened). Both thematically and game-wise I feel like it should be set up so that spraying everyone is a desperate last resort (high risk high reward) gamble, not as a no-brainer. If it should be sprayed day 1, why not just dispense with the canister and give everyone powers to begin with? For that matter, why would the UO be looking for it?Scoop20906 wrote:
2. bb2112 had the Terrigen Mist on night one and chose to spray it on everyone. However, the Unspoken One/Vorret had other ideas and killed him. No, he didn't bb2112 had the canister. This through everything off as I thought everyone would have powers.
It's also kind of odd that the UO is better off having the humans spray everyone than stealing the canister and using it, since the results are identical except that if the humans spray everyone then the UO gets another human death out of it.
One suggestion: remove the part where a human user dies if they spray everyone, and as before the humans can huff the canister individually. Make one of the humans at start be the Scientist (or something). Both the Scientist and the UO are scanning for Unobtanium held by a random human. If either finds it then everyone gets sprayed, but if the Scientist finds it the spray is better for the humans and if the UO finds it the spray is better for the Inhuman side. (either an extra power for someone, or an extra kill or something, whatever makes sense in terms of balancing).
Anyway, fun game - I would play again.