Scoop20906 wrote:El Guapo wrote:Scoop - I'd like to hear your thoughts on my post analysis. For what it's worth, based on day 1 and day 2 posts alone, I would vote for RMC. Though as noted there's not a TON of posts to go on.
But that runs into the Occam's razor that the guy claiming Red Rocket and inviting to be lynched is probably not the final villain.
Good analysis but not really much to mine from. We got lucky in that we were given two evil scans without much analysis from Issy on why he chose them. Neither Vorret or Moliere had much interaction with Grund or RMC. Grund was his normal day one/two quiet and RMC had his reasons even if he was Red Rocket.
And thats the thing. Red Rocket and Elongated Man are two heros who are perfect hiding spots for an villain. Both have built in reasons for why they would stay silent. I didn't care much for Grund's "breadcrumbs" or his trap statement but they do fit a plausible pattern. RMC was masterful in the way he announced his role if he is faking. If he is not faking he came out at the right time as well.
Really? I got no clue but I do know this. RMC can play the innocent villager role very well. That why I eventually choose to vote for him.
Yeah, that sums it up pretty well - they're both plausible villain candidates, they were both silent day 1 and day 2 (incidentally, the innocent party here could have helped themselves considerably by opening their yapper), they both claim roles that make a profile more explicable, etc. etc.
In terms of actually making a decision between the two of them, I think we just have to play the odds. RMC coming out as Red Rocket under minimal duress and when he could have claimed silent is crazy. Could be crazy as a fox of course, but just on an odds / Occam's razor basis, you have to figure that he's *probably* not faking. By contrast Grund spoofing when he did is much more logical and understandable - it makes much more sense than RMC's alleged spoof play.
And honestly, your reasons for voting RMC don't make a ton of sense. RMC "can" play the innocent villager role - I'm sure that's true, but he also "can" actually be an innocent villager, so that doesn't seem like much of a tool for rooting out whether he's innocent in this case. You also said that you're usually wrong, but then presumably that would also apply to you being wrong about things, which means that you should go with what you originally thought, so...
Grundbegriff
May God have mercy on our souls. I'm probably mostly done eating the planet anyway.
Anyhow Scoop, I'm going to be in a training for most of the morning. You can either complete your Scooping destiny here, or alternatively make the case for me to vote RMC - I am a reasonable planet-eating entity (what exactly is Galactus, anyway - an animal? A mythical creature? Regardless).
Black Lives Matter.