bb2112 wrote:You name him and Stess can confirm. 4 provens.
Seeing as though I am concerned about even giving out my Normal scan - because I am concerned about exposing MM, I would think it's obvious I'm concerned about exposing MM directly.
However, what you are pointing out is exactly the thing that's been driving me nuts, because I can also give us an additional scan with that 'proof', but 1) nothing I say is proven until I die, and 2) the conversion could mean that MM or one of the two love birds is not worthy of our care, (or me, for that matter). I'm just not really going down that road too far at this point. Either way, there are 2-3 Villains that started the game not as Heroes or Normal, and we should look for them in some manner. (and while RMC was
perhaps one, I still sorta fear he wasn't)
So, on balance I just don't like the idea at all of handing them the name of MM; but I so struggled with that opinion. Ultimately I felt this was a good compromise. I like sorta 'half proving' myself to stessier and perhaps MM by stating that I know MM is not the 2 players I've 'presented'. What I don't like is the
me 'taking control' part of that.
The alternative is attractive to me, but it's riddled with problems too. That's why I was open to hearing options, but I feel like I've already mulled over many of them. (still listening)
El Guapo wrote:So if Unagi is telling the truth, a named Martian Manhunter would mean a guaranteed double night kill, since he already scanned / protected MM and this would put us at our hero quota, meaning there's no Flash around.
Yes, the fact that I knew MM and knew that I could never protect him is exactly what was behind this statement:
Unagi wrote:You should not reveal the name of Martian Manhunter at this time (if ever).
He must contact a player each night, and if Martian is killed they would both die.