Re: New WW Variant-Wild Wild West - Roles are out - Game on!
Posted: Wed Aug 09, 2017 2:27 pm
or let RMC shoot him.Vorret wrote:I'm inclined to believe this, plus, if we all vote for NC we don't need Seer protection
That is not dead which can eternal lie, and with strange aeons bring us some web forums whereupon we can gather
http://www.octopusoverlords.com/forum/
or let RMC shoot him.Vorret wrote:I'm inclined to believe this, plus, if we all vote for NC we don't need Seer protection
Let's shoot Scoop!!!!Vorret wrote:*If* we believe all claims so far :
Good :
Holman - Dead
Vorret - Drunk
Punisher - Seer
RMC - Outlaw
Lassr - Lawyer
Evil :
Newcastle
Unknown :
El Guapo
Unagi
Scoop
I am cool with this, and I think Scoop is the other wolf if Punisher is telling the truth.El Guapo wrote:Wow. Ok then. If there's a different seer out there I think they should come forward and announce themselves as well. But since Punisher wasn't really taking much heat I think it's pretty likely that he's telling the truth.
Assuming that he is, probably worth using RMC's shot on Newcastle and then using the Sheriff to protect Punisher, right?
Scoop!!!Punisher wrote:So, assuming you believe me and assuming RMC shoots (or maybe not if NC gets all the votes)
what is the consensus on who I should scan tonight (my vote is not needed in the above 2 scenarios)
No one listens to the town drunk.....Vorret wrote:I'd scan either Unagi or El Guapo at this point, maybe Unagi first since he has a habit of gaining the confidence of the group.
We may have a few false claims here and there though (and tomorrow we'll know whether you're lying or not)
I misread your power, so we have zero worry about who dies tonight if you kill someone, am I understanding right?RMC wrote:Scoop!!!Punisher wrote:So, assuming you believe me and assuming RMC shoots (or maybe not if NC gets all the votes)
what is the consensus on who I should scan tonight (my vote is not needed in the above 2 scenarios)
And no votes matter tonight, for I will shoot Newcastle!
5. Outlaw - Auto kill vote 1 time per game. This will take the place of the kill. The outlaw submits 2 names - if one name is the Sherriff's then the Sherriff is automatically chosen for the kill. The auto kill is negated and used up if the person chosen was protected by the Sherriff. The person with the most votes will die instead.
I have my choice on who to use as choice two, since we know who is not the sheriff by virtue of claims. I guess the wolfs know who might be the sheriff as well. But we can handle that Thursday.
The first one dies if none are the sheriff I remember seeing that somewherePunisher wrote:It doesn't say, but what happens when you put 2 names in and neither is the Sheriff.. Do both die or you get to choose your main target?
If you choose then it's simple..
NC and me. This will definitively prove one of us.
BB can you confirm how that works?Vorret wrote:The first one dies if none are the sheriff I remember seeing that somewherePunisher wrote:It doesn't say, but what happens when you put 2 names in and neither is the Sheriff.. Do both die or you get to choose your main target?
If you choose then it's simple..
NC and me. This will definitively prove one of us.
there you go Punisher, knew I read that somewherebb2112 wrote:Most votes, and if there are ties with the most votes, then all the top voters get killed. Supposed to be a quick game.Unagi wrote: bb, so is it 'the most votes' or is a majority needed still?
He has the one time ability to kill someone. Being an outlaw, if in the confusion he can off the Sherriff, then he is going to do it. He submits 2 names, if the second name on his list is the Sherriff, then the Sherriff will get killed instead of whomever was at the top of the list. Otherwise his first choice will be killed.Unagi wrote: Also - the Outlaw seems to not really be helpful for the good guys at all? does his power only kill the sheriff? not sure if I get his role.
Cool... As long as RMC puts the names in the correct order we are fine.. and if RMC is NOT the outlaw somehow, the real one should do this as we are down to 1 wolf then. Worst case, I am lying and you guys off me tomorrow.Vorret wrote:there you go Punisher, knew I read that somewherebb2112 wrote:Most votes, and if there are ties with the most votes, then all the top voters get killed. Supposed to be a quick game.Unagi wrote: bb, so is it 'the most votes' or is a majority needed still?
He has the one time ability to kill someone. Being an outlaw, if in the confusion he can off the Sherriff, then he is going to do it. He submits 2 names, if the second name on his list is the Sherriff, then the Sherriff will get killed instead of whomever was at the top of the list. Otherwise his first choice will be killed.Unagi wrote: Also - the Outlaw seems to not really be helpful for the good guys at all? does his power only kill the sheriff? not sure if I get his role.
(page 2 if anyone doesn't believe me)
bb2112 wrote:He has the one time ability to kill someone. Being an outlaw, if in the confusion he can off the Sherriff, then he is going to do it. He submits 2 names, if the second name on his list is the Sherriff, then the Sherriff will get killed instead of whomever was at the top of the list. Otherwise his first choice will be killed.Unagi wrote: Also - the Outlaw seems to not really be helpful for the good guys at all? does his power only kill the sheriff? not sure if I get his role.
Remember there is not a guaranteed outlaw in the game, only that there would be only one.Vorret wrote:It would have been insanely dumb to fake the outlaw role on day one since the real outlaw would simply have killed the spoofer that night so there's zero reason to doubt RMC.
Ohh, you're right, good point, oh well , you'll be proven soon enough.RMC wrote:Remember there is not a guaranteed outlaw in the game, only that there would be only one.Vorret wrote:It would have been insanely dumb to fake the outlaw role on day one since the real outlaw would simply have killed the spoofer that night so there's zero reason to doubt RMC.
I mean I am the outlaw, and when we see poor wolfy newcastle sprawled out with a bullet hole in his forehead, I shall be proven. But there could not have been an outlaw..
COUNTERPOINT: It would be hilarious if RMC accidentally put the names in the wrong order and shot the wrong person by accident. Especially if it were himself, although I'm pretty sure that you can't name yourself as the second (as that would eliminate the whole Outlaw drawback).Punisher wrote:Cool... As long as RMC puts the names in the correct order we are fine.. and if RMC is NOT the outlaw somehow, the real one should do this as we are down to 1 wolf then. Worst case, I am lying and you guys off me tomorrow.Vorret wrote:there you go Punisher, knew I read that somewherebb2112 wrote:Most votes, and if there are ties with the most votes, then all the top voters get killed. Supposed to be a quick game.Unagi wrote: bb, so is it 'the most votes' or is a majority needed still?
He has the one time ability to kill someone. Being an outlaw, if in the confusion he can off the Sherriff, then he is going to do it. He submits 2 names, if the second name on his list is the Sherriff, then the Sherriff will get killed instead of whomever was at the top of the list. Otherwise his first choice will be killed.Unagi wrote: Also - the Outlaw seems to not really be helpful for the good guys at all? does his power only kill the sheriff? not sure if I get his role.
(page 2 if anyone doesn't believe me)
El Guapo wrote:COUNTERPOINT: It would be hilarious if RMC accidentally put the names in the wrong order and shot the wrong person by accident. Especially if it were himself, although I'm pretty sure that you can't name yourself as the second (as that would eliminate the whole Outlaw drawback).Punisher wrote:Cool... As long as RMC puts the names in the correct order we are fine.. and if RMC is NOT the outlaw somehow, the real one should do this as we are down to 1 wolf then. Worst case, I am lying and you guys off me tomorrow.Vorret wrote:there you go Punisher, knew I read that somewherebb2112 wrote:Most votes, and if there are ties with the most votes, then all the top voters get killed. Supposed to be a quick game.Unagi wrote: bb, so is it 'the most votes' or is a majority needed still?
He has the one time ability to kill someone. Being an outlaw, if in the confusion he can off the Sherriff, then he is going to do it. He submits 2 names, if the second name on his list is the Sherriff, then the Sherriff will get killed instead of whomever was at the top of the list. Otherwise his first choice will be killed.Unagi wrote: Also - the Outlaw seems to not really be helpful for the good guys at all? does his power only kill the sheriff? not sure if I get his role.
(page 2 if anyone doesn't believe me)
Nobody appreciates great comedy.Punisher wrote:El Guapo wrote:COUNTERPOINT: It would be hilarious if RMC accidentally put the names in the wrong order and shot the wrong person by accident. Especially if it were himself, although I'm pretty sure that you can't name yourself as the second (as that would eliminate the whole Outlaw drawback).Punisher wrote:Cool... As long as RMC puts the names in the correct order we are fine.. and if RMC is NOT the outlaw somehow, the real one should do this as we are down to 1 wolf then. Worst case, I am lying and you guys off me tomorrow.Vorret wrote:there you go Punisher, knew I read that somewherebb2112 wrote:Most votes, and if there are ties with the most votes, then all the top voters get killed. Supposed to be a quick game.Unagi wrote: bb, so is it 'the most votes' or is a majority needed still?
He has the one time ability to kill someone. Being an outlaw, if in the confusion he can off the Sherriff, then he is going to do it. He submits 2 names, if the second name on his list is the Sherriff, then the Sherriff will get killed instead of whomever was at the top of the list. Otherwise his first choice will be killed.Unagi wrote: Also - the Outlaw seems to not really be helpful for the good guys at all? does his power only kill the sheriff? not sure if I get his role.
(page 2 if anyone doesn't believe me)
Ah..yes. hah ha.. it would be funny... not... I'm leaning towards scanning you tonight now!
Sorry.. There was no town fool role listed...El Guapo wrote:Nobody appreciates great comedy.Punisher wrote:El Guapo wrote:COUNTERPOINT: It would be hilarious if RMC accidentally put the names in the wrong order and shot the wrong person by accident. Especially if it were himself, although I'm pretty sure that you can't name yourself as the second (as that would eliminate the whole Outlaw drawback).Punisher wrote:Cool... As long as RMC puts the names in the correct order we are fine.. and if RMC is NOT the outlaw somehow, the real one should do this as we are down to 1 wolf then. Worst case, I am lying and you guys off me tomorrow.Vorret wrote:there you go Punisher, knew I read that somewherebb2112 wrote:Most votes, and if there are ties with the most votes, then all the top voters get killed. Supposed to be a quick game.Unagi wrote: bb, so is it 'the most votes' or is a majority needed still?
He has the one time ability to kill someone. Being an outlaw, if in the confusion he can off the Sherriff, then he is going to do it. He submits 2 names, if the second name on his list is the Sherriff, then the Sherriff will get killed instead of whomever was at the top of the list. Otherwise his first choice will be killed.Unagi wrote: Also - the Outlaw seems to not really be helpful for the good guys at all? does his power only kill the sheriff? not sure if I get his role.
(page 2 if anyone doesn't believe me)
Ah..yes. hah ha.. it would be funny... not... I'm leaning towards scanning you tonight now!
I threatened to vote for him.Vorret wrote:nevermind, nobody vote for you. carry one, it makes sense
No, I mean, what I was about to say is you can't be the politician since the vote ended 3 vs 3 for RMC/Holman so it wouldn't have made sense if he switched a vote but it makes sense if nobody voted for him.RMC wrote:I threatened to vote for him.Vorret wrote:nevermind, nobody vote for you. carry one, it makes sense
But if everyone is telling the truth and no one ever lies in these games.
It means that Unagi or El Guapo is the wolf, right?
Lassr claimed Lawyer, check againRMC wrote:oops... Nope I am wrong.. Here we go:
1. Vorret - Drunk
2. Punisher - Seer
3. Scoop - Politician
4. El Guapo - ?
5. Unagi - ?
6. Newcastle - Wolfy (Alpha)
7. RMC - Outlaw
8. Holman - Dead
9. Lassr - ?
Forgot about Lassr
So I was right the first time. Knew it.... But I don't trust Scoop. He smells like a Red Rocket to me...Vorret wrote:Lassr claimed Lawyer, check againRMC wrote:oops... Nope I am wrong.. Here we go:
1. Vorret - Drunk
2. Punisher - Seer
3. Scoop - Politician
4. El Guapo - ?
5. Unagi - ?
6. Newcastle - Wolfy (Alpha)
7. RMC - Outlaw
8. Holman - Dead
9. Lassr - ?
Forgot about Lassr
There can be only one outlaw, sheriff and seer.Scoop20906 wrote:I am the politician. I'm pretty sure there can only be one.