It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

If it's a video game it goes here.

Moderators: LawBeefaroni, Arcanis, $iljanus

Post Reply
User avatar
Fitzy
Posts: 2030
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 4:15 pm
Location: Rockville, MD

It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Fitzy »

Are there any examples of good economies in an RPG?

I most recently played Pillars of Eternity 2 and while money was a bit tight the first few levels, I'm now pretty sure I could buy every island. Looking back, it seems like every single player RPG is the same way.

Dragon Age: Origins is the only one I remember having to make some compromises even to the end on gear to purchase. The Gothic games I think were relatively money light, but they also didn't have much to spend on, so I don't recall having issues in the end game.

Beyond just end game struggles, I was thinking that RPGs are unrealistic in the handling of money. Dumping massive amounts of armor and weapons on the potion selling guy. There is no scarcity of either money or items.

DAO gave the illusion of an economy by having limited resources at the end game, though it was still an illusion.

Is it even possible to build a realistic seeming economy in a single player RPG without making it boring?

I've only played SWTOR as an MMO, so I'm uncertain if they are any better. TOR's economy suffered from a lack of consistency. There was almost a player driven economy sometimes, but drops were better, except sometimes player crafted stuff could be better, until the next patch when they flopped again.
User avatar
Alefroth
Posts: 8486
Joined: Thu Oct 14, 2004 1:56 pm
Location: Bellingham WA

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Alefroth »

I guess it depends on what you mean by good. It sounds like for you, scarcity means good.

I'm not expecting a realistic economy in a game where so much else is unrealistic. I'd think a realistic economy would be frustrating more than boring. I don't want a Monty Haul, but I also don't want to spend so much time just managing money either.
Last edited by Alefroth on Thu Jul 19, 2018 1:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Blackhawk
Posts: 43487
Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2004 9:48 pm
Location: Southwest Indiana

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Blackhawk »

Some of the mods for Elder Scrolls titles heavily rework the economy to adjust to the player's spending habits. Dump gazillions of gold into the local economy on iron ingots and inflation goes nuts, the price of iron skyrockets, the nearest towns with iron mines get rich, etc.
(˙pǝsɹǝʌǝɹ uǝǝq sɐɥ ʎʇıʌɐɹƃ ʃɐuosɹǝd ʎW)
Freyland
Posts: 3041
Joined: Sat Jan 01, 2005 11:03 pm

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Freyland »

Prophecy of Pendor mod for Mount and Blade: Warband had a pretty good economical component. Plus first-person beat-down's never get old.
Sims 3 and signature unclear.
User avatar
Alefroth
Posts: 8486
Joined: Thu Oct 14, 2004 1:56 pm
Location: Bellingham WA

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Alefroth »

I haven't played it yet, but it seems like Kingdom Come: Deliverance may have tried for the realism you're looking for.
User avatar
stimpy
Posts: 6102
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 6:04 pm

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by stimpy »

It has been awhile, but I don't remember economics playing that big of a part in KC:D.
In fact, if I recall, I never really found much better armor or weapons than those found early in the game, so money was never an issue.
He/Him/His/Porcupine
User avatar
Fitzy
Posts: 2030
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 4:15 pm
Location: Rockville, MD

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Fitzy »

Alefroth wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 12:07 pm I guess it depends on what you mean by good. It sounds like for you, scarcity means good.

I'm not expecting a realistic economy in a game where so much else is unrealistic. I'd think a realistic economy would be frustrating more than boring. I don't want a Monty Hall, but I also don't want to spend so much time just managing money either.
Yeah, I suppose scarcity is what I’m looking for. I think maybe challenge would have been a better for me to use, with scarcity as a component. I agree that an actual realstic economy would be boring. Though having teamsters haul away the loot after I’ve killed everything might be amusing. :D
Blackhawk wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 12:10 pm Some of the mods for Elder Scrolls titles heavily rework the economy to adjust to the player's spending habits. Dump gazillions of gold into the local economy on iron ingots and inflation goes nuts, the price of iron skyrockets, the nearest towns with iron mines get rich, etc.
I didn’t realize they’d gotten that advanced. I haven’t tried it in years, thanks.

I’ve never played KC:D or Mount and Blade, thanks for the suggestions!
morlac
Posts: 3898
Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 4:25 pm
Location: Just outside the ATL

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by morlac »

Freyland wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 12:14 pm Prophecy of Pendor mod for Mount and Blade: Warband had a pretty good economical component. Plus first-person beat-down's never get old.
Best Mod of any game ever :) Nice obscure reference as well.


IMO I should be filthy rich towards endgame and money should not be a problem. I AM the Hero and have the loot to prove it.
morlac
Posts: 3898
Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 4:25 pm
Location: Just outside the ATL

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by morlac »

More thoughts: Is the economy broken or the game mechanics. Example: It doesn't really matter if John the Herbalist will buy anything and has bottomless cash to do so If I couldn't carry 12 weapons, 2 sets or armor, 5000 shiny baubles, 100 iron ingots, and 1 Minotaur head. So is the economy stupid or the strength of my back and bottomless pockets?
User avatar
Fitzy
Posts: 2030
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 4:15 pm
Location: Rockville, MD

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Fitzy »

morlac wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 12:37 pm More thoughts: Is the economy broken or the game mechanics. Example: It doesn't really matter if John the Herbalist will buy anything and has bottomless cash to do so If I couldn't carry 12 weapons, 2 sets or armor, 5000 shiny baubles, 100 iron ingots, and 1 Minotaur head. So is the economy stupid or the strength of my back and bottomless pockets?
Could be either. In Morrowind I used to dump all the loot at the entrance of the dungeon, mark, load up, cast one of the intervention scrolls, sell stuff, recall... Obviously I was exploiting a game mechanic, but trying to “realistically” haul limited items to the store gets boring. I could not sell every little bauble, but the game seems to demand it.

I used to think the problem was a single coin type, such as gold, causing issues with pricing, such as an apple being worth the same as a dagger. DA:O used different coins, gold was precious. But... PoE2 used a single low level coin and the higher level ones were simply stored as 3x, 4x whatever the smaller denomination. Still ended up out of whack.

I have no idea what the answer is, especially in open games where one player could just do the main quest and another rob every house, do every side quest. I’ve just noticed that as RPGs move towards the end, they get easier and one aspect of that is the economy. I suppose I could limit myself, but I grew up in the 80s :D

Some of this comes from the LitRPG genre. I’ve been reading a few of them lately and they gloss over the economies for the most part or the economies are greatly exploited. It made me start thinking about what a good economy would look like in an RPG.
User avatar
Lorini
Posts: 8282
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 8:52 am
Location: Santa Clarita, California

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Lorini »

World of Warcraft has a huge economy. But you may not want to pay the sub. The nice thing about their economy is that you can make enough gold not to have to pay a sub.

Eve Online also has a big economy, don't know how they are doing subs now. Path of Exile has a big funky economy, I could never figure it out.
Black Lives Matter
User avatar
Pyperkub
Posts: 23583
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:07 pm
Location: NC- that's Northern California

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Pyperkub »

The Witcher 3 seemed to have a pretty good balance (at least as far as I've gotten - Level 23+/Skellige)
Black Lives definitely Matter Lorini!

Also: There are three ways to not tell the truth: lies, damned lies, and statistics.
User avatar
coopasonic
Posts: 20968
Joined: Fri Mar 04, 2005 11:43 pm
Location: Dallas-ish

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by coopasonic »

Pyperkub wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:44 pm The Witcher 3 seemed to have a pretty good balance (at least as far as I've gotten - Level 23+/Skellige)
Witcher 3 is another game where you go from pinching pennies at the beginning to building out your own villa at the end with cash left over. In fact, the villa at the end may have been added specifically to deal with the fact that you have so much money in the end game, despite vendors with limited cash on hand.
-Coop
Black Lives Matter
User avatar
NickAragua
Posts: 6100
Joined: Mon Feb 23, 2009 5:20 pm
Location: Boston, MA

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by NickAragua »

coopasonic wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 3:36 pm
Pyperkub wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 2:44 pm The Witcher 3 seemed to have a pretty good balance (at least as far as I've gotten - Level 23+/Skellige)
Witcher 3 is another game where you go from pinching pennies at the beginning to building out your own villa at the end with cash left over. In fact, the villa at the end may have been added specifically to deal with the fact that you have so much money in the end game, despite vendors with limited cash on hand.
It didn't help. Geralt still had enough money to singlehandedly destabilize the Nilfgaardian economy. And every other economy. Not really sure why he's running around killing monsters, but it's not for money, I'll tell you that much.
Black Lives Matter
User avatar
Blackhawk
Posts: 43487
Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2004 9:48 pm
Location: Southwest Indiana

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Blackhawk »

Fitzy wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 1:31 pm Obviously I was exploiting a game mechanic, but trying to “realistically” haul limited items to the store gets boring. I could not sell every little bauble, but the game seems to demand it.
And yet, did it actually, or was that just an impression? I'd bet that you could play Morrowind without ever selling a single piece of loot unless a quest specifically demanded it.
(˙pǝsɹǝʌǝɹ uǝǝq sɐɥ ʎʇıʌɐɹƃ ʃɐuosɹǝd ʎW)
User avatar
Lorini
Posts: 8282
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 8:52 am
Location: Santa Clarita, California

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Lorini »

A good example of why player run economies are just better. Single player games that aren't actually business games have a hard time balancing all of the economic stuff, I've found.
Black Lives Matter
User avatar
Fitzy
Posts: 2030
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 4:15 pm
Location: Rockville, MD

Re: It's the economy stupid (RPGs)

Post by Fitzy »

Blackhawk wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 3:50 pm
Fitzy wrote: Thu Jul 19, 2018 1:31 pm Obviously I was exploiting a game mechanic, but trying to “realistically” haul limited items to the store gets boring. I could not sell every little bauble, but the game seems to demand it.
And yet, did it actually, or was that just an impression? I'd bet that you could play Morrowind without ever selling a single piece of loot unless a quest specifically demanded it.
🤨🤔

Huh. Maybe i need to play again.
Post Reply