Kraken wrote: ↑Wed Mar 04, 2020 12:06 pm
Victoria Raverna wrote: ↑Wed Mar 04, 2020 2:17 am
I guess Sanders' ideas are too extreme for the voters?
Not his ideas; those poll well, and many are mainstream now (compared to 4 years ago). For example, M4A remains controversial, but a public option is not. It's Bernie himself who's too extreme, with his "my way or the highway" attitude.
I don't disagree that Bernie himself is seen as too extreme and his attitude is alienating. But I think it's the echo-chamber effect that has many thinking that his ideas are mainstream. I just don't see that.
Taken out of context and in the abstract, lots of people sign on to "the idea" of M4A or free college or cancelling medical debt or an estate tax on "millionaires and billionaires," but it's not telling us much to take those ideas out of context and in the abstract. I mean, really, are the vast majority of people that are staring down scary college tuition and dealing with medical debt really going to say, no, I hate the idea of free college or cancelling debt? If you ran for student president in high school on a platform of a 4 day school week, that idea would probably poll pretty well in the abstract, too. But if you disclosed that that policy would also require the school year to run through a good chunk of your summer vacation due to state requirements on the number of required school days annually, I'm pretty sure that support would evaporate.
I just don't think polling on Bernie's ideas - to the extent is suggests these ideas are now "mainstream" - really tells us much. People aren't tuned in to the details, and they're not keeping their eyes on how his biggest ideas would actually be implemented.
I thought this Axios article,
"A Reality Check on Bernie Sanders' Biggest Ideas" laid out some of those practical, contextual considerations that are not adequately reflected in the polls.
While I buy that extreme income inequality is a significant challenge and one that needs to be addressed, I continue to believe (hope) that "mainstream" thinking in this country remains that we are and should continue to be a society founded on the principles of liberal individualism and free market capitalism with the backstop of a generous social safety net.