How exactly were you going to prevent the scenario I described? Isn't it the case that your karma incremented at Console Gold and at OO? What exactly were you going to do to ensure that you didn't end up entitled to two games for your one? Will every participant do the same?
i already said - i offer a certain game on both forums, my karma goes up by 1 on both forums... if i claim a game on either forum, my karma on both forums goes down by 1 - what makes you think i was doing otherwise? as Aussie77 said, i too thought the final agreement on this issue was 'if you can keep track of it, go ahead and do it'.
EDIT: as for "how would i make sure that everyone else would do the same" - well, how exactly would i go about doing that? i'm not 'everyone else' - i would hope they were honorable as well.